Date: Wed, 15 Jun 94 20:01:02 EDT From: articles@drum.ncsc.org (Various Information) 1993 NCARRV Report In the ten years since NCARRV was founded, there has been a significant shift in the sources of racial violence. Perpetrators of bigoted violence are less likely to be members of explicitly racist organizations, and more likely to be unaffiliated individuals. Yet racist organizing continues, and intolerance of differences between people seems more difficult than ever to overcome. In fact we have witnessed backward steps: tolerance of bigoted, racist and hateful actions has become more widespread. Incidents of violence have increased in all areas of society, regardless of motivation. And bigotry continues to present itself as an excuse for violence, instead of a reason for its condemnation. Despite certain noteworthy victories over organized hate groups, which includes successful criminal & civil litigation, the key symbols of Klan activity - cross-burnings, racial slurs and harassment, vandalism, glorification of white supremacy - continue to serve as rallying points. The climate of fear and mistrust that such activities create continues to incubate hatred and violence. It is urgent in such an environment to find ways to interrupt the cycle of escalating violence and fear, to encourage understanding of the common difficulties of communities suffering through economic dislocations, lack of significant opportunities, and epidemics of crime and drugs. Yet from many quarters, we hear a growing call for a new kind of tolerance, as if all it would take to end the violence were an acceptance that things have gotten better and will continue to improve. If African-Americans were to "get the chip off their shoulder" so whites could carry through on their commitment to "color-blindness" the problem would magically disappear. It has become"rude" to insist on calling attention to the continuing inequities, to deplore the absence of significant efforts to improve the conditions of poor communities (white or black), or to locate responsibility for the epidemic of crime and violence in our society in long-standing patterns of discrimination against, under-investment in, and outright exploitation of impoverished non-white communities. Yet these problems continue to exist, in many cases even to grow worse. Despite progress in calling attention to systematic practices of bigotry and violence, there is less frank discussion now of on-going racial inequities and people's anxieties about race than there was 10 years ago. We have seen a systematic retrenchment of affirmative action laws. A new "politics of scarcity" has slashed funding for social programs. Once intended to create opportunities for African-Americans, these programs are now less capable of meeting the needs of anyone. Finally, mutual understanding and support as the moral foundations for dealing with racism have given way to a crude selfishness and racial isolationism. The result is a new level of bottled-up rage, punctuated with outbreaks of anger by individuals and sometimes by entire communities. As NCARRV re-aligns itself for the next decade, it is clear that our focus must widen from hate groups like the Klan to include the more embarrassing problem of continued disparities in the treatment of white and non-white people in this country. We must get past the recriminations and one-sided charges of "black racism" and "white racism" - there is only one racism, and these are simply different manifestations of it. Until we can get past the mistrust and name-calling and move on to roundly condemn all acts of violence and aggression, whether perpetrated by a black youth, a white home-owner, or a police officer, the situation can only deteriorate. One of the most troubling tendencies in our society at large has been the emphasis on personal isolation as a solution to social problems. Communities with wealth draw back into themselves and hire more armed guards and policemen; more crimes than ever draw jail sentences and prison time; impoverished communities find themselves barricaded, ignored, invisible; would-be immigrants are turned back while no thought is given to how to create opportunities in their own countries. The most unfortunate manifestation of this thick-skinned indifference to the plight of those who are "different" is to be found in the courts and criminal justice system. The ethnic intimidation act has become a new tool in the intimidation of minority populationsQfar more non-white citizens have been prosecuted and convicted, and those convicted have received harsher sentences than their white counterparts. The violent victimization of non-white people, homeless people, homosexual people and others continues to receive far less attention than violence directed at heterosexual white people, despite the fact that a much higher percentage of people in those minority groups are victimized. It is no surprise that youth end up suffering the brunt of these developments. After all, youth cannot insulate themselves in the ways adults attempt. They cannot avoid interacting with each other and must establish their own social arrangements. But more than ever, positive role models are lacking. There are precious few examples of adults effectively addressing problems of race, sexuality, or economic opportunity. The situation of young people is a barometer of adults' capacity to create a supportive, functional society. By that measure, these are bleak times indeed. Still, we cannot afford to give up hope, nor to despair in our struggle for a decent life for everyone. We must continue to insist on fairness and equity in all aspects of our lives, particularly on the part of those entrusted with the enforcement of law and justice. We must remedy lack of opportunities by creating new opportunities, not by redistributing the shrinking number that already exist. Finally, we must be mindful of every person's pride and dignity, even as we challenge the symbols of bigotry and hatred that divide us. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- NCARRV was established to eliminate bigoted violence in North Carolina by educating residents about the escalation of incidents of bigoted conflict and the prejudices from which such violence arises. NCARRV accomplishes this mission through monitoring and research; victims' assistance; community organizing, educating, and networking; and by suggesting changes in public policy. In 1983, NCARRV began sounding the alarm about the rise in extremist activity and bigoted violence. Now NCARRV is recognized as the main monitoring agency for hate activity in North Carolina, and as a national model for countering white supremacist activity and hate violence. NCARRV's data predicts trends and offers solutions as problems emerge. NCARRV has worked in the trenches all across North Carolina in communities experiencing hate group organizing and bigoted conflict. NCARRV has also worked to build bridges between and among a wide range of constituencies affected by hate violence rising from racism, anti-Semitism, and homophobia. NCARRV began staffed operations in 1985. Based in Durham, North Carolina, NCARRV is a 501(c)3 organization with approximately 600 members and two staff members, numerous volunteers and interns. Its Board of Directors meets quarterly and the annual meeting is held in November. Dues are $20 per year for individuals and a sliding scale of $30 to $100 for organizations. NCARRV is supported by a number of foundations, including but not limited to the Z Smith Reynolds Foundation; the Fund for Southern Communities; the Funding Exchange; United Church Board of Homeland Ministries, United Church of Christ; Public Welfare Foundation; RESIST; the Durham/Chapel Hill Jewish Federation; the Greensboro Justice Fund; the Bryan Family Foundation; and the Paul Green Foundation. This report was compiled and written by the staff and volunteers of North Carolinians Against Racist and Religious Violence: Christina Davis-McCoy, Executive Director Linda Shealey Williams, Community Educator/Field Coordinator Jeremy Raw, Volunteer Ann Burlein, Volunteer Andrew Neather, Volllnteer Typesetting by Kelly Martin, Willow Graphics Printing by GrassRoots Press NCARRV's Board of Directors are: Alease Alston, President Lee Wood, Treasurer Rev. Clarence Bryan Linda Moore Dr. Alton Pollard, III John Tracy, Esquire *** *** ANALYSIS 1993 can be characterized as one of the most violent years in recent North Carolina history. There were a total of 147 incidents, up from the 138 documented in 1992's report. Although there wasn't a tremendous upsurge in the overall number of incidents, the intensity of violence has certainly increased. There were far greater assaults and aggressive physical contact between individuals, especially among young people. The number of harassment complaints doubled. The prevalence of violence may be a factor in this marked aggresslon. In 1993, the number of murders doubled compared to 1992. Most of the murders involved racial conflict and conflict between youth or involved youth. The number of anti-gay incidents more than doubled from 1992's report - 29 to 60. It is clear that many North Carolina citizens have discomfort with its gay and lesbian citizens. Below is a breakdown of documented conflict and its comparison with 1992. l993 ... l992 35 ..... 19 ****Assaults 13 ..... 20 ****Vandalism 05 ..... 09 ****Cross burnings 42 ..... 23 ****Harassment 06 ..... 10 ****Slurs 08 ..... 12 ****Leafletting / Literature 01 ..... 02 ****Arson 08 ..... 04 ****Murders 22 ..... 30 ****Klan organizing (legal and illegal) 07 ..... -- ****School conflict (tensions) _________________________________________ 147 .... 138 ***Total _________________________________________ 24 ..... 19 ****Incidents involving youth 60 ..... 26 ****Incidents that were anti-gay Although the organized Klan activity was less than that documented last year, the level of intensity increased significantly. With the February Wilson bank robbery, open recruitment in KKK robes in Salisbury, and the murder carried out by a skinhead in Winston-Salem, the state of North Carolina can not afford to ignore white supremacist movements. As regards young people and assaults, our state's leaders and citizens have not yet dealt with conflict played out by its young people. The state demonstrated its lack of understanding when it focused attention on removing guns and weapons from the public schools rather than ask the question "Why do youth feel they need to be protected?" And what of this notion that violence is the answer when dealing with conflict and difference? In our society it appears that whoever exhibits the greatest level of violence gets the most respect. We have teenagers walking around thinking they can not get respect without carrying a gun. Not only is there the issue of lack of self esteem among many young people, but also creative, realistic ways to deal with conflict in a nonviolent manner. The state's ethnic intimidation act was applied to six publicly known cases last year. State agencies we contacted were unable to provide concrete data on cases tried under the state ethnic intimidation statute. Of the cases cited in newspapers, the first case was in January in Wake county where two white men assaulted a group of Vietnamese in a Raleigh pool hall. It is not known if the case has gone to trial. The second case occurred in January also, this time in Gaston county where a group of black youth attacked a white student after an athletic event. Thirteen youth were charged, one gaining a three year suspended sentence while the others plea bargained or had charges dropped due to lack of evidence. The third charge was again black on white where in Transylvania county three Job Corp students attacked a white student. The February incident concluded with the three black males given a two year probationary sentence and dismissed from the Job Corps. The fourth ethnic intimidation charge came in March where in Surry county a white man threw jugs of urine on the lawn of an African-American police officer. That charge was later dismissed. The fifth charge came in July where in Rockingham county two white teenagers conducted a harassment campaign against an African American student. Even though they had been charged with attacking this same student at an earlier date and that there was racial animus, the teenagers received light punishment. One was given a one year sentence suspended for two years, a fine and community service. The other was just given 50 hours of community service. The final charge of ethnic intimidation in 1993 was sited in Orange county where a group of black teenagers assaulted an interracial group. The teens were charged with calling a black victim an "Oreo". Two young men charged received the harshest sentence given in 1993 for ethnic intimidation. They were given four days active jail time, a one year suspended sentence, two years supervised probation, 50 hours community service,an 11:30 curfew, and ordered to pay the victim's $7,000 medical bill. Three prosecutions were undertaken for blacks assaulting whites, while two were for whites assaulting blacks. Sentences for black offenders were stricter than for whites in cases where convictions were won. The use of this act needs to be examined. HATE GROUPS IN NORTH CAROLINA Although the number of Klan rallies, marches, and other activities decreased slightly from 1992's report, we can not ignore the fact that white supremacist groups need to be closely monitored in North Carolina. Christian Knights of the Ku Klux Klan This group is still under the national leadership of North Carolina's Virgil Griffin. Griffin and the state's Grand Dragon Rev. Charles Beasley continue to push for the group's visibility in the state with weekend marches in communities across the state. Although Griffin has had some medical problems, the group has continued to develop chapters from Charlotte to Wilson. Because of the climate created when the Klan marches in communities, cities such as Wilmington, Salisbury, and Greensboro continue to look at creative alternatives for its citizens. The cost associated with Klan marches has some wondering how to charge Klan members for a faction of the cost of police protection while struggling with the First Amendment. As our economy worsens and scapegoating continues, it will be necessary for cities and towns to develop tactics to respond to the frustration many feel when they see the Klan marching down their streets. Invisible Empire Knights of the Ku Klux Klan This KKK faction lost a major civil rights battle with the Southem Poverty Law Center. James Farrands, national leader and residing in Sanford, and his group lost not only $37,000 but office equipment, their membership list and their monthly paper The Klansman. The group reportedly adopted a new name and assumed operations more or less underground. The Invisible Empire had the reputation of being the most violent Klan faction in the United States. Its members carried out harassments and murder across the United States. The success of the lawsuit demonstrates how the legal system can effectively slow down white supremacist groups. The Confederate Knights of America, National Socialist Front This neo-Nazi group, led by Huntersville's Terry Boyce, has the potential of being the most deadly group in our state because of their ability to recruit young people. In February of this year two members of this group were arrested for robbing a Wilson bank. Before it ended, the pair led police on a dangerous carchase through the streets of Wilson. In Winston-Salem, an organizer for this group was charged with the murder of a white teenager who had black friends. Apparently this was the motivation for his murder. Winston-Salem, known for its conservative nature, was plastered with recruitment fliers from the Confederate Knights of America, National Socialist Front, and dealt with a number of racial tensions in 1993. There are, however, some individuals who prescribe to white supremacust ideology and hide behind religion. Nord Davis, of the Northpoint Teams, publishes Christian Identity literature and a newsletter called "On Target". Davis, who was listed in our 1991 Annual Report for spreading Christian Identity literature in the western part of our state, has been harassing NCARRV and its executive director Christina Davis-McCoy. Nord Davis has written literature criticizing Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr., dedicating it to Ms. Davis-McCoy in an effort to discredit her and NCARRV. In regards to the other groups we have here in North Carolina, such as the Populist Party, Kirk Lyons and CAUSE, and various factions of the Christian Identity movement, very little movement has been documented by NCARRV. That may be due to the "protective stance" many of this groups have taken since the February Wilson bank robbery. Whatever the reason, we do know that these groups and individuals continue to preach and distribute their message of hate and ignorance to many North Carolinians. We need to be able to effectively counter those messages. RECOMMENDATIONS FOR REMEDIES: NCARRV 1993 ANNUAL REPORT North Carolinians Against Racist and Religious Violence has consistently illuminated trends which suggest the need for public education, ardent advocacy, and specific policy redress in the North Carolina community. Our reporting on issues of bigoted attack, community unrest, police/community conflict, and youth has followed in that tradition. Our work has continued in the hope of creating a climate in the state which values the dignity and worth of all North Carolina residents and calls for accountability of those to whom that responsibility is entrusted. As we observed in putting together documentation for 1993, one clear trend which has emerged is the pervasive climate of violence in the larger community and society. Fanning the flames of hysteria over violent criminality feeds the fear of some citizens, and in turn, desensitizes others of us who should be outraged when we hear of fear-based violence. Unfortunately in these situations, there is ultimately more value given to the protection of material goods and property, than to the life of another human being, even when not directly making any life-threatening action. There are several incidents documented in this report which we feel result directly from the racially charged climate and from prejudicial hysteria regarding crime and potential criminals. Two typical examples of such incidents are the Durham shooting deaths of Jamal Elliot, a fourteen year old African American male and twenty-two year old Simon Rodriquez, a Latin man, both killed by citizens. Overall documentation for 1993 reflects conflict, tensions and violence in 46 counties in the state, with a logged total of 147 incidents. The fires of intolerance are still raging and burning in North Carolina. The Z. Smith Reynolds Foundation issued the results of a survey commissioned in 1993 which revealed that Whites and Blacks in North Carolina "view different realities but agree that race relations are (a) serious problem in (the) state". Of the more than 800 North Carolinians questioned, "large majorities of blacks and whites perceived that the races have negative opinions about and feelings toward each other". The survey was completed by Howard, Merrell, and Partners, a Raleigh based marketing and public opinion organization. Measures of seriousness of the problem included the statistics that " 32% of whites and 38% of blacks think that violent racial disturbances similar to those in Los Angeles will occur in North Carolina in the next few years, More than eight in ten whites and blacks believe that racial problems among North Carolina middle and high school students are serious." We applaud the wisdom and vision of the Z. Smith Reynolds Foundation for this significant research. It certainly echoes what we have been hearing and saying at NCARRV for the past ten years. What is even more painfully clear is the continued need for local and state govemment intervention to ease tensions and provide guidance and support of programs which create opportunities for people to move beyond intolerance toward mutually respectful relationships. And while there must be attention given to individual relationships, there must also be concentration on reforming historically biased institutions, shoring up weak infrastructures that currently fail to address human relations issues, and creating new ones where none exist. We again call on Governor Jim Hunt to recommission the statewide Task Force on Racial, Religious, and Ethnic Intimidation and Violence. Work on this task force, commissioned by Governor James Martin in 1988, only scratched the surface of the root causes of remaining conflict and violence. While the outcomes of the victims's reporting network, law enforcement human relations training, and an ethnic intimidation statute are laudable accomplishments; there are still many other steps aimed at restoring mechanisms in communities for redress and clear public education which must be explored with the bountiful resources of the state of North Carolina. We further urge that re-establishing human relations commissions in every county of the state and developing an anti-bias curriculum for use in all North Carolina public schools be specific tasks of the recommissioned body. Only when we have come closer to extinguishing the fires of intolerance and bigoted violence in North Carolina, may we call ourselves a "World-class Community". Since the implementation of North Carolina's Ethnic Intimidation Act, NCARRV has insistently urged that concerted steps be taken to remove ambiguities existing in the legislation which make it difficult for courts, citizens, and law enforcement agencies to apply the law as it was originally intended. With the publication of this report and based on NCARRV's monitoring of how the statute has currently been applied, cases prosecuted reflect a disproportionate racial imbalance in convictions and sentencing. Blacks have been convicted at twice the rate of whites under this new statute and received more severe punishment than their white counterparts. In our efforts to secure statistical data on convictions to date covered under the statute from the Governor's office, the State Bureau of Investigation (SBI), and the Administrative Offices of the Courts, we were advised that no data was available. This raises once again serious questions for us at NCARRV about how the effectiveness of a law can be measured if clear data is unavailable on its use. Secondly, we are concerned that without clear information which can substantiate the usefulness of this statute in the state,it may jeopardize extension of the Federal Hate Crimes Statistics Act of 1990. In light of our findings, we recommend that serious consideration be given to developing standards for application of the Ethnic Intimidation Act which will restore it to it's intended use. These standards would do much to clarify how the statute should be used and to address concerns of the current ambiguities involved in interpreting and applying the law. With the release of this report for 1993, as has been the case over the past eight years, NCARRV's documentation of anti-gay violence ranks second only to racially motivated violence. Conservative estimates suggest that gay men and lesbians comprise ten percent of the total population. Yet few national, state, or local protective measures exist for individuals who are harassed, assaulted, and murdered because of their sexual identities. Passage of the Federal Hate Crimes Statistics Act of 1990 clearly sets precedent for the establishment of protective mechanisms for this population, as clearly as the exclusion of their protection only continues to legitimate their victimization. We strongly recommend the inclusion of sexual identity in North Carolina's ethnic intimidation statue and the Civil Rights Interference Act to serve as a deterrent to would-be perpetrators of crime against gay men and lesbians in this state. THE CHRONOLOGY Methodology Documented incidents include racist, religious, and anti-gay violence as well as constitutionally protected Klan and neo-Nazi activity such as meetings, rallies, electoral activity, and other forms of organizing. This document incorporates the following working definition of bias crime used by the California Racial, Ethnic, and Religious Violence Task Force: "Any act to cause physical injury, emotional suffering, or property damage, which appears to be motivated, all or in part, by race, ethnicity, religion, or sexual orientation." Below is a chronology of incidents of bigoted conflict in North Carolina in 1993. The events in this chronology are classified by types as follows: A = Assault or fight V = Vandalism C = Cross burning H = Harassment O = Organized by Klan, neo-Nazi, or other supremacist group S = Slur or reported remark L = Leafletting or literature M = Murder F = Arson An additional classification of some events is made in the following areas: X = Anti-Gay Y = Youth involvement, as victims or perpetrators R = Motivated by victim's religion Following each incident is NCARRV's sources of information presented here. Those sources include: Newspaper clippings The Anti-Defamation League (ADL) The North Carolina Human Relations Commission (HRC) The North Carolina Coalition for Gay and Lesbian Equality (NCCGLE) The Center for Democratic Renewal (CDR) National Association for the Advancement of Colored People (NAACP) Klanwatch, Southern Poverty Law Center Local and state law enforcement Field research by NCARRV staff Victim's reports DECEMBER 1992 incidents: Davidson Co. The NAACP held a press conference on December 31 to announce that the chapter is considering filing a lawsuit against Sheriff Jimmy Johnson. They contend that the sheriff's department has unfairly fired or denied promotions to African American employees. They also allege that the Sheriff has used racist language when referring to black people. (January 2, Winston-Salem Journal) JANUARY ** Y #1. January, Orange Co. A student residence hall at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill was the site of ugly racial harassment. In one of the dormitory bathrooms, someone placed a flier which read: "This bathroom is no longer desegregated. No niggers allowed except for the housekeepers." (Feb. 8, Daily Tar Heel) Surry/Wilkes Co. The Elkin Board of Education approved an advisory council to monitor race relations in the Elkin school system following allegations of racial tensions at Elkin High School. (January 21, Winston-Salem Journal) C C A #2,#3,#4. January 1, Haywood Co. Two crosses were burned at the Waynesville home of a white woman who was involved in an interracial relationship. She was the target of harassing phone calls two weeks before the cross burning. The FBI were called in to investigate it as a civil rights violation. This incident fell on the heels of two other racially motivated incidents in Waynesville. On Aug. 8, 1992, a white Waynesville police officer was assaulted with rocks, bottles and his patrol car window smashed after the officer responded to a call to break up a fight between black and white youth. A week later, a fight broke out at the shopping mall between a black man and a white man. (January 3 and 5, Asheville Citizen-Times) H X #5. January 5, Wake Co. City council member Mary Watson Nooe proposed that private businesses be required to observe Raleigh's non-discrimination policies (which currently protect city employees against discrimination, including those based on sexual orientation). Adam McManus (director of Citizens Against Pomography) and the Wake County Christian Coalition organized to defeat Noce's proposal. Nooe received several death threats. Council member Anne Franklin received harassing telephone calls from opponents. (NCCGLE) January 8, Columbus Co. A news article from the Wilmington Morning Star reported that the Columbus County school system has been cleared of charges that it discriminated against African American students. A complaint was filed that the school system placed African-American children in programs for the mentally impaired and that African-American males were more likely to be punished. The US Department of Education agreed that African-American students "are significantly under-included" in academically gifted classes but felt there was no evidence that the school discriminates. A #6. January 9, Wake Co. Two men were charged with ethnic intimidation following a fight between whites and Vietnamese at a pool hall in Raleigh. The suspects allegedly called the men "chinks", "gooks", and "slopes" and began swinging pool sticks and punching them. Raymond John Zimmer and Mark Hammond were charged with felony assault with a deadly weapon and ethnic intimidation. Zimmer is also alleged to have taken a pager from one of the victims and left numerous messages threatening to kill him. (January 16, Raleigh News and Observer) M #7. January 15, Union County. Guy Mitchell Brown and Russell Brice Hinson were charged with the crossbow death of a sixteen year old. Felicia Hope Houston of Monroe died after she was struck by a bolt from a cross bow on December 28. Although Hinson was a KKK leader in Union Co in the late 1988s and was convicted of assaulting a black man in 1987, authorities speculated that the incident was not racially motivated although the victim was black and the two men were riding through a predominantly black neighborhood. Monroe Public Safety Chief Bobby Kilgore said Felicia was in the wrong place at the wrong time and that the incident was "a drug deal gone bad." Hinson was sentenced to life in prison on December 16 after a jury deadlocked whether to give him the death penalty. Prosecutors say that Hinson killed Felicia Houston "to send a message to the black community". Guy Mitchell Brown turned state's evidence and under a plea agreement, the murder charge was dropped. He was given three years in prison for accessory to murder after the fact. He has served eleven months and is scheduled to be released soon. Testimony at the trial illustrated that Hinson indeed had racial prejudices. Lt. Derry Simpson, jail administrator and longtime friend of Hinson's testified that Simpson had a "black or dark blue mannequin that appeared to be holding a football or a watermelon" that he would use for target practice. (January 15, Charlotte Observer, December 16 and 27, Charlotte Observer) O #8. January 17, Rowan Co. Forty members of the Christian Knights of the Ku Klux Klan marched in Salisbury. Forty-five officers dressed in riot gear surrounded them as they made their way down Main Street. (January 14 and 18, Salisbury Post) A A #9,#10,#11. January 20, Watauga Co. Appalachian State student Paul Dodson was assaulted off-campus at a local bar. When he went to the University Health Services for treatment, he was assaulted again by the same assailant. Dodson reported the attacks as "gay-bashing." City police, however, never interviewed Dodson; instead, they wrote on the police report as fact a hearsay statement repeated by bar owner Joe Todd that accused Dodson of sexually assaulting his assailant. After the campus newspaper revealed Dodson's name but protected his attacker's, Dodson withdrew charges, quit school, and attempted suicide. One week before Dodson's assault, another student had beenbeaten in the same bar by a man yelling "You faggot!" repeatedly. No charges were filed. Earlier that month, an African-American student pledging to a fraternity was beaten when its members found out he was gay. The student was hospitalized with kidney damage. He did not press charges. (NCCGLE) L #12. January 21, Cumberland Co. Flyers from the Confederate Knights of America, National Socialist Front were put under car windshields outside a bowling alley on Raeford Road in Fayetteville. (NCARRV, victim's report) V Y #13. January 22, Orange Co. MacNider Hall, part of the School of Medicine at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill was vandalized with "scrawlings suggesting hate crimes against blacks, including profanity." (January 26, Durham Herald-Sun) #14. January 23, Orange Co. At UNC-Chapel Hill, a white student verbally assaulted a black Morrison dorm resident. (February 8, Daily Tar Heel) A X #15. January 23, Wake Co. A gay male was assaulted by a man with a gun who raped him twice, robbed him, forced him to call several friends to pay money so he would not be killed, and then threatened to disclose his sexual orientation to his family if he told police (which he did not). (NCCGLE) V X #16. January 25 - 31, Watauga Co. Graffiti was written on the bathroom wall at Appalachian State that said: "Beat the hell out of a fag. Apps Anti-Homo Hate Club. Club sponsored gay-bashing - Join the fun! Fags have no rights. Homosexuals must die. Make the world a better place . . . Kill a fag. Fags caused AIDS. F--- you faggot (sic)." Someone painted the name of the campus gay and lesbian student group in a circle with a slash across it. (NCCGLE) A Y #17. January 27, Gaston Co. A group of black youth surrounded a white teenager after a game at Hunter Huss High School in Gastonia. While kicking and punching the youth, they shouted "Malcolm X" and "Rodney King." The incident was believed to have been provoked when a white police officer asked a group of black teenagers to leave the parking lot but said nothing to the white teenager. Thirteen black students, who ranged in age from 14 to 19, were suspended from school for 10 days and were charged with assault inflicting serious injury for racial intimidation. On December 14 Darrius Jefferies was sentenced to three years probation and ordered to pay a portion of the victim's medical bills. Other defendants are working on plea bargains or had charges dropped for lack of evidence. (December 15, The Charlotte Observer, January 29, Gaston Gazette, February 2-3, Gaston Gazette) V Y #18. January 29 or 30, Moore Co. Racial slurs were spraypainted at Pinecrest High School. The slurs included references to the KKK, swastikas, satanic symbols, and slavery. It was discovered on the outside of four buildings, four school buses, two activity buses, and two vans. Following this vandalism spree a 14 - year old eighth grader brought a gun to school and was suspended for 10 days. (February 4, Southern Pines Pilot) A X #19. January 30, New Hanover Co. Three Marines were charged with the beating of a gay man in a club in Wilmington. The beating was viewed as a backlash against President Clinton's lifting of the ban on gays in the military. The Marines were later acquitted after claiming they attacked in self-defense. (February 2, Jacksonville Daily News, April 14, Wilmington Morning Star) FEBRUARY ** S #20. Mecklenburg Co. A Charlotte man received a bill from Sears addressed to "APURE COON" (sic). Sears officials maintained that a former employee entered the slur into its computer. Sears offered an apology and refunded the victim's last payment. (February 19, Charlotte Observer) H X #21. February 2 & 6, Watauga Co. A 16-year-old lesbian was accosted by a man who cursed "G-damn f---ing Boone dykes." Four days later when the woman was shopping at the mall with gay friends, the same man was part of a group who followed the woman and her friends through stores, coming up to them one at a time and muttering slurs. (NCCGLE) H X #22. February 4, Watauga Co. A lesbian was followed by a man in a car who drove up behind her in the parking lot and blocked her in for 20 minutes. The incident took place the day after the Appalachian State school paper published a letter she had written protesting its printing the name of a man who had been gay-bashed. (NCCGLE) H X #23. February 4, Watauga Co. A lesbian who works at Appalachian State received a harassing call at work. The call came the morning after the school paper published a letter the woman wrote protesting the paper's publication of the name of a man who was gay-bashed. (NCCGLE) February 5, Davidson Co. Davidson County commissioners decided not to approve the Martin Luther King, Jr holiday as a paid holiday for county employees. Instead the board voted to allow county employees to use a vacation day to observe the King holiday. (February 6, Winston-Salem Journal) Y #24. February 5, New Hanover Co. Students at two schools in Boiling Spring Lakes left school early in response to rumors of a big fight. South Brunswick Middle School and High School were patrolled by seven sheriff's deputies and many parents came to pick their kids up early. Rumors centered around racial tensions when white students began wearing rebel flags on their clothing and displaying rebel flags on their vehicles. (February 6, Wilmington Morning Star) A Y #25. February 5, Caldwell Co. A fight involving black and white students erupted after a basketball game at West Caldwell High School. Twelve officers responded and there were over one hundred onlookers. The fight recalled the stabbing deaths in 1991 of two African-American male students in the hallwaysof West Caldwell High School. The youth were stabbed by two white youth who were later acquitted of murder. (February 6, Lenoir News-Topic, NCARRV) C #26. February 5, Johnston Co. A cross is burned at the home of a Native American in Benson. The victim reported that it was the second act of vandalism at his residence within two weeks. Although the victim was involved in an interracial relationship, law enforcement stated "the crime appears to be a domestic dispute rather than a hate crime." (February 9, Raleigh News and Observer) S #27. February 7, Orange Co. In Chapel Hill, conduct was called into question when black transportation employees complained of racial slurs directed towards them by white employees. It was later decided that the department would undergo sensitivity training for all employees. (February 7, Chapel Hill Newspaper) O #28. February 9, Wilson Co. Two members of the Confederate Knights of America, National Socialist Front robbed a bank in Wilson and led police on a chase and shootout. Kurt Eugene Latimer and Linwood Paul Pittman were charged with robbery. Latimer was arrested at the scene, Pittman eluded officers, kidnaped an elderly man at gunpoint and forced him to drive to Virginia. Pittman gave himself up two days later. (February 21, Raleigh News and Observer) A Y #29. February 11, Transylvania Co. Three black Schenck Job Corps students were discharged from the center after they were charged with ethnic intimidation for assaulting a white student in a dorm. They pled guilty to misdemeanor assault and ethnic intimidation, received two-year probationary sentences and were discharged from the Job Corps. (March 5, Hendersonvile Times-News) H X #30. February 15, Bladen Co. 175 people from the Bladen County Coalition of Christians presented petitions with 2,500 names requesting the Board of Commissioners to revise library book selection policies after it purchased three gay-affirmative children's books. Commissioner Fred Bowen received a threatening call by someone claiming to be a Coalition member. (NCCGLE) V X #31. February lR19, Wake Co. Notices of the first Gay and Lesbian Awareness week posted in the Free Expression Tunnel at NC State University were defaced. On Friday, two hours after the notices were restored, someone painted homophobic graffiti, including a picture of a person with a gun shooting "two dead faggots" and slogans like "Why do you think God invented AIDS? Think about it." (NCCGLE) A #32. February 20, Brunswick Co. A white Leland woman was raped by a white man in retaliation for her involvement with a black man. The interracial couple were on their way to visit friends when they were accosted by four white men. Three of the men chased the boyfriend while the fourth man, "hollering she didn't belong with no nigger", and that "whites belong with whites and blacks belong with blacks," raped and assaulted the woman. The rapist was captured by law enforcement and charged with first-degree rape and jailed under a $100,000 bond. (March 4, Wilmington Morning Star) C #33. February 21, Mecklenburg Co. A cross was burned at the home of a southeast Charlotte woman. (February 22, Gastonia Gazette) H X #34. February 23, Watauga Co. A gay student at Appalachian State University received a homophobic flyer about "Bill Clinton's Queen Berets" in university mail. The flyer was sent by "Students Against Sexual Crimes and Homosexism." (NCCGLE) H X #35. February 28, Orange Co. Hoping to cut funding to B-GLAD (UNC-Chapel Hill's gay and lesbian group), conservativestudents Darren Allen and Chris Tuck released a confidential list of 63 people who had attended a B-GLAD meeting. Three students whose names were on the list received threatening phone calls. This fall, the new B-GLAD co-chair received letters postmarked nationwide all containing a photocopy of the list with "devil" scrawled next to his name and threats like "A bullet through your head, faggot." (NCCGLE) MARCH ** Durham Co. A Duke University professor claimed he was the victim of racial discrimination and was rejected for tenure. The forty-year old African American filed charges with Duke and the Federal Equal Employment Opportunity Commission. (March 2, Raleigh News and Observer) A X #36. March, Orange Co. A man reported that a 19-year-old youth was gay-bashed. (NCCGLE) Wake Co. The DollHouse, a Raleigh strip club, became the subject of a state and federal probe after black men reported being denied membership with the club. (March 19, Raleigh News and Observer) Macon Co. The site of the white supremacist Church of the Creator was purchased by William Pierce, former leader of the American Nazi Party, in July of 1992 for $100,000. He is now attempting to sell it for $299,900. The listing described "property and three buildings ideally suited for a group or organization which wants a headquarters where it can host meetings, training sessions, or retreats of up to 40 members or guests." (March 9, Asheville Citizen-Times) A Y #37. New Hanover Co. A parent group expressed concern after a white junior high school teacher allegedly struck a black student with a notebook. (March 16, Wilmington Morning Star) H #38. March 2, Durham Co. The North Carolina Minority Support Center reported a message left on their voice mail by someone who claimed he was the "Grand Wizard of the Charlotte KKK". He said he was calling for a meeting but left a phone number which was disconnected. (NCARRV victim's report) H X #39. March 3, Guilford Co. Two gay men received harassing calls on their answering machine. They are prosecuting. (NCCGLE) H #40. March 3, Durham Co. A woman involved in an interracial marriage reported to NCARRV that someone left a message on their message machine "Hey is anybody home, any body there? I got the bomb." The woman suspected someone from an auto repair place they visited was responsible for the call. The woman's husband is from West Africa and has a bumper sticker on his car which reads "stop the bomb habit". (NCARRV victim's report) A X #41. March 4, Onslow Co. A man assaulted Linda Papineau, secretary for 30-Minute Muffler, which had sponsored a radio program in which Crae Pridgn spoke about being beaten by three Marines. Before hitting her the man said: "I want you to know what I think of your business promoting (homosexuals)." (NCCGLE) A Y #42. March 11, Forsyth Co. Three black Carver High School students were arrested following an attack believed to have stemmed from racial tensions evoked by white students carrying Confederate Flags to school. The episode led school administrators to host a school forum on resolving racial conflicts a few days later. (March 12 and 13, Winston-Salem Journal) March 18, Durham Co. A black teenager is killed while fleeing a home he attempted to break in to. Fifteen year old Jamal Elliott was shot four times in the back by white homeowner Michael Seagroves. Seagroves chased Elliott and three other black teenagers from his property and shot at them as they fled. The incident created tensions in the community with residents split over whether Seagroves was justified in the shooting. Seagroves was charged with manslaughter and aggravated assault. In a December trial the jury deadlocked. Attorney General Mike Easely announced in late January 1994 that the state would not retry the case. (March 20 Durham Herald-Sun, NCARRV staff report) O #43. March 21, Caldwell Co. Members of the Christia-n Knights of the Ku Klux Klan marched in Lenoir. (NCARRV monitoring report) V X #44. March 22, Guilford Co. Posters advertising a talk about gays in the military were vandalized at UNC-Greensboro's library. (NCCGLE) H #45. March 23, Surry Co. A white man was charged with ethnic intimidation after several incidents where jugs of urine were thrown into the yard of a black police officer living in a predominantly white neighborhood. H X #46. March 25, Mecklenburg Co. A woman listed as a contact for a bisexual support group received a harassing call. (NCCGLE) H Y #47. March 29, Buncombe Co. Members of the Theta Chi fraternity from UNC-Asheville harassed a black student who had been hired by the University to paint over fraternity and sorority symbols on a road leading to the campus. Rocks and eggs were thrown at a police car called to the scene. The fraternity was put on probation in 1992 when a member was seen wearing a racial slur written on a hat during a televised UNC Asheville vs Western Carolina basketball game. (March 31, April 1, Asheville Citizen-Times) H X #48. March 29, Mecklenburg Co. Someone yelled "faggot" into a classroom at UNC-Charlotte apparently after seeing a notice posted on the classroom door identifying the lecture as gay-oriented. (NCCGLE) V #49. March 30, New Hanover. A concession stand, freshly painted for the N.C. Azalea Festival, was defaced with swastikas and skulls. (March 31, Wilmington Morning Star) A Y #50. March 30, Wake Co. A black Zebulon Middle School student was attacked by white youth after an altercation on a school bus. Racial slurs were allegedly made during the assault. (April 1, Wendell Gold Leaf Farmer) H X #51. March 30, Mecklenburg Co. Two gay men at a restaurant were verbally harassed by four men. Management was supportive and promptly called police. (NCCGLE) H X #52. March 30, Orange Co. A gay man received a threatening message. (NCCGLE) V X #53. March 31, Mecklenburg Co. A flyer announcing Gay, Lesbian and Bisexual Week at UNC-Charlotte was torn down and replaced with an anti-gay flyer. (NCCGLE) H X #54. March 31, Orange Co. An openly gay UNC student received two harassing calls. It was reported to police. (NCCGLE) APRIL ** April, Durham Co. A caller reported that someone bashed in the door of his car. The car was parked at the entrance of a hiking trail where anti-gay vandalism often occurs. (NCCGLE) April 1, New Hanover Co. A gay bar is fire-bombed in Jacksonville. Three Molotov cocktail bombs were thrown into the bar after it received much publicity surrounding gays in the military. No one was injured. The previous month ten hangmen's nooses and notes saying "Faggots die" were left outside the bar. Danny Leonard, the bar's owner, has received three to four threatening calls a week since March (120-160 calls). Two weeks before the arson, Marines wielding baseball bats turned up at the bar, but no one was injured. On February 5, the bar was targeted by an anti-gay rally attended by only four protesters. (April 3, Wilmington Morning Star, NCCGLE) M #55. April 2, Robeson Co. In Maxton, a nineteen year old black youth, Terry Curtis Williams, is murdered by a white convenience store clerk after a fight over a pack of cigarettes the clerk believed was stolen from his store. Racial tensions boil as hundreds gather to protest the following weekend. Willie Dockery Steed is charged with second degree murder. (Aril 5, Laurinburg Exchange) H X #56. April 6, Mecklenburg Co. A gay man was informed by co-workers that his boss was telling them not to talk to him. (NCCGLE) A #57. April 9, New Hanover Co. In Wilmington a white male was assaulted at a fast food restaurant by two black men who called him "racial names" while hitting him with their fists. (April 16, Wilmington Morning Star) O O #58,#59. April 10, Mecklenburg Co. The Christian Knights of the Ku Klux Klan marched in Charlotte and Matthews. (April 12, Gastonia Gazette, NCARRV) V #60. April 14, Caldwell Co. Vandals struck Davenport Elementary School in Lenoir, spraypainting a wall with "KKK" and "Hems #1"(sic). (April 15, Lenoir News-Topic) H #61. April 17, Wilson Co. A victim contacted the NCARRV office to report a series of harassing phone calls made to her home and a restaurant she owned. The phone calls were followed by a fire which destroyed her business. The victim reported to NCARRV that the previous owner of the restaurant was connected with the Klan and did not want to see her succeed. Untrue rumors were spread that her cook was HIV positive in an attempt to keep people from eating at her restaurant. The restaurant was burned twice until it was destroyed. No one was ever charged for the arson. (NCARRV victim report) April 20. Members of a House subcommittee, the Judiciary II committee, killed a repeal of the state's crime against nature law, which has been used against gays and lesbians in the state. The bill died a fast death because some committee members saw it as a way to "legitimize homosexuality". (April 23, Raleigh News and Observer) H X #62. April 21, Wake Co. In Raleigh, a gay travel agency sent promotional materials to a list of people presumed gay. Someone returned the materials with hateful comments scrawled upon them. (LGHP, NCCGLE) L #63. April 21, Forsyth Co. In Winston-Salem flyers were distributed downtown by someone advertising for the National Socialist Front. The message read "White Power Forever, What about White Civil Rights?" (NCARRV victim's report) April 21, Nash Co. NCARRV staff was called to Rocky Mount to investigate problems at a high school there. Concerned black residents questioned why blacks had to enter the school from the back while white students entered from the front. They also maintained that black students were being sprayed with Mace. In a meeting with the superintendent, teachers and parents were assured that their concerns would be studied and an effort would be made to hire more black teachers. (NCARRV victim's report) April 23, Orange Co. The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill's Faculty Council approved a plan that will require freshmen and sophomores from fall 1994 onward to take a least one course studying cultural diversity. (April 25, Chapel Hill Herald) C #64. April 25, Cleveland Co. A cross is burned at the home of a Swainsville resident. (April 27, Shelby Daily Star) L Y #65. April 26, Forsyth Co. Radst notes were left on the dorm rooms of four Salem College students. The notes read "Niggers Go Home" and another was addressed to a white student involved in an interracial relationship, calling her a "nigger lover". The incident prompted school officials to host forums with students to discuss the incident and race relations on campus. Salem College, a four year women's college has about 800 students, 5% of them minorities. (June 20, Winston-Salem Chronicle) April, Mecklenburg Co. Charlotte residents found themselves in a middle of a battle when Freedom Park, used by youth to showcase their cars, was closed. The park, frequented by mostly young African-Americans, was closed after residents near the park (who are mostly white) complained of loud music and people urinating in their yards. (April 30, Charlotte Observer) A #66. April 30, New Hanover Co. A man was assaulted and called a racial slur after he turned in front of a car on Oleander Drive in Wilmington. The driver of the second car made an obscene gesture after the victim cut in front of him. The driver then followed the victim into a shopping center, got out of his car, called the man a "nigger" and attacked him. The suspect left the scene after the fight. (May 2, Wilmington Morning Star) M #67. April 30, New Hanover Co. The body of a black male was discovered by a fisherman at Greenfield Park in Wilmington. Twenty-five year old Tony Robinson died a week later after being beaten into a coma. Police suspected the slaying may be related to the fact that Robinson was gay. No suspects have been charged. Local activist Leo Teachout told NCCGLE that Robinson's murder followed the same pattern as several other unsolved murders since the early 1980s in which gay men were killed during the same time that police begin publicly conducting sting operations targetting gay men in local parks. (May 8, Wilmington Morning Star, NCCGLE) MAY ** May, Guilford Co. A resident of a half-way house called to report she was assaulted by another resident who said she was "queer" and tried to push her through a window glass. One day later, the caller was discharged from the home while the assailant was allowed to stay. Caller is filing a complaint. (NCCGLE) May, Orange Co. A group of young men at a party talked about killing gay people. (NCCGLE) H X #68. May, Durham Co. A woman who lived in a house where a gay man also lived called to report that a neighbor erected a sign on her lawn reading "Gays live over there." When confronted by the caller, the neighbor accused the caller, who is not gay, of rolling around and kissing on the front lawn with another woman. The victim called police, who at first were unresponsive, but eventually asked the neighbor to remove the sign. (NCCGLE) H X #69. May, Orange Co. A teacher who was involved in a controversy over including gay and lesbian literature in a multicultural program received a death threat. (NCCGLE) May 5, Mecklenburg Co. Jim Ivey, who identified himself as a "proud Klan member", wrote a letter to the Charlotte Observer stating "the Klan will be around protecting white rights as long as the NAACP is around protecting black rights." (May 5, Charlotte Observer) Y #70. May 5 - 7, Polk Co. Students at Polk Central High School in Columbus had Sheriff's deputies patrolling the halls and metal detectors installed at the school after a series of incidents that may have been racially motivated. On Wednesday, May 5, a black student sprayed four white students with Mace. That incident led to a fight between a black student and a white student. The student responsible for spraying the Mace was later suspended. The letters "KKK" were found on a bathroom stall that same day. The next day, deputies searched students with metal detectors and found seven pocket knives. Polk, with a student population of 550 students, 12% black (60 students), planned to undergo group conflict resolution and sensitivity training. (May 8, Asheville Citizens Times) A #71. May 7, Gaston Co. A West Gastonia softball coach was charged with two counts of assault after pointing a gun at two teens. The incident occurred during a game between the girls' West Gastonia team and the Bessemer City team. Coach Billy Joe Johnson reportedly became upset because, in his words, "This black boy (sic) had been mouthing off during the entire game." The youth was cheering for the other team. It was reported that Johnson used a racial slur during the incident. (May 9, Gastonia Gazette) O #72. May 8, Catawba Co. The Christian Knights of the Ku Klux Klan marched in Conover. (May 10, Hickory Record) H #73. May 8, Madison Co. A car belonging to an interracial couple was shot into and racial slurs were painted in the road in front of their home. The couple had only lived there for two weeks. (May 13, Asheville Citizen-Times) May 19. The Ku Klux Klan faction the Invisible Empire Knights of the Ku Klux Klan lost a civil case filed by civil rights marchers attacked in Forsyth County, Georgia in 1987. The suit, filed by the Southern Poverty Law Center, forced the Invisible Empire, led by North Carolina resident James Farrands, to pay $37,500 in damages, turn over its office equipment and give up its name. The settlement also barred the group from using its mailing lists and the name ofits newsletter, The Klansman. (May 20, Roanoke Rapids Herald) A X #74. May 25, Guilford Co. A gay man was assaulted by two men in a parking lot who yelled "Faggot" and "Take it like a woman" as they beat him. Caller reported that police acted as if he deserved the beating and told him to find out the names of his assailants on his own. (NCCGLE) May 27, Forsyth County. The Winston-Salem Journal reported a former Food Lion employee alleged the supermarket chainhad a "policy of sending out-of-date meat from area stores to the Food Lion store on North Claremont Avenue because the store catered to black people." Bobby R. Woollen, former market manager at Food Lion, stated that the meat manager in 1992 told him to send out-of-date meat to the store because ". . . food stamp time was coming up and the Clermont (sic) Store could move the product". In later months Food Lion dropped the out-of-date meat policy. (May 27, Winston-Salem Journal) JUNE ** June. A study by the NC Division of Youth Services revealed that black youths make up 70% of the enrollment in state training schools even though only half of the juveniles arrested each year are black and only 32% of the state's juvenile population is black. Researchers looked at case files from 1990 in 10 counties. They found that Johnston, Buncombe, Caldwell, Cumberland, and Forsyth counties sent more black children to training schools than Brunswick, Haywood, Wilkes, Robeson, and Guilford counties. (June 29, Charlotte Observer) M O #75. June 3, Forsyth Co. A neo-Nazi leader was charged with the death of a white youth killed apparently because he had black friends. Twenty year old Aaron Harrison Moser, leader of the Winston-Salem chapter of the Confederate Knights of America, National Socialist Front, was charged with the murder of Thomas Joseph Scharf and the shooting of Julius Johnson, a black friend of Scharf. The incident occurred after Moser spotted Scharf and Johnson with others standing at Clemmonsville Road. Words were exchanged and shots were fired. (June 5, Greensboro News and Record) O #76. June 6, Guilford Co. Forty-six members of the Christian Knights of the Ku Klux Klan marched in High Point. The march drew 100 spectators, some of them supporters. Speakers included Rev. Charles Beasley, NC Grand Dragon and Horace King, SC Grand Dragon. (June 7, Winston-Salem Journal) H X #77. June 14, Wake Co. A gay man called to report a campaign of intimidation, extortion, discrimination and harassment. When the caller disclosed his sexual orientation to a co-worker, the co-worker began to blackmail him. When the caller reported this to his employer, his employer demoted the caller, and joined the co-worker in making death threats and harassing the caller, his roommate and his family. The caller reported this to police, who were indifferent, and is pursuing legal action. (NCCGLE) June 26, Wake Co. At this year's Pride March held in Raleigh, about two dozen protesters (mostly from Johnston County) screamed at marchers to repent and carried signs that read,"Homosexuals want to indoctrinate school kids." (NCCGLE) A #78. June 27, Lenoir Co. In LaGrange, a white convenience store clerk shot a black customer, leaving him paralyzed from the waist down. Twenty year old Nico Hood was shot by sixty year old Norman Potts after an argument in the store. The argument followed Potts's refusal to sell pastries to Hood and his friends because one of the young men had been "banished" from the store. Potts reportedly fired upon Hood after Hood pulled a gUll from his pocket. Potts was charged with assault with a deadly weapon with intent to kill. Members of a citizens' group marched, protested, and showed up at town council meetings to express their outrage over the state of race relations there. (September 26, Raleigh News and Observer) A X #79. June 28, Durham Co. Linda Evans was assaulted by her mother for "being a g-- d---- lesbian." The mother abducted Evans' two children and took them to their father (who last year tried to take the children from Evans because she is a lesbian; he is now prohibited from seeing the children unless authorized). The father refused to return the children until forced by the sheriff. Evans noted that police "were great" and is pursuing legal action. (NCCGLE) L #80. June 29, Guilford Co. Greensboro police found signs warning blacks not to harm whites in certain parts of the city. The signs read: "Waming. Hate crimes against whites will not be tolerated. We are watching. KKK". Police believe the signs are in retaliation to a beating of two white men at Morningside Homes on June 23, in which one suspect has been charged. An informant to the police department said "one white person would be beaten for every black person arrested in the area by a white officer." (June 30, July 3, Greensboro News and Record) June 30, Mecklenburg Co. A gay man reported that in November 1989 his girlfriend demanded $4,000 or she would reveal his sexual identity. He is currently pursuing legal action. (NCCGLE) JULY ** M #81. July 3, Robeson Co. A white Red Springs police officer, Lt. James Howard Edwards, was charged with first-degree murder in the shooting death of Julian Williams, an African American, who was involved in a relationship with Edwards's daughter. The shooting occurred after Officer Edwards heard that his daughter was treated at a local hospital for wounds she allegedly received from Williams. Mr. Williams was shot up to sixteen times in the head and body. Lt. Edwards turned himself in thirty minutes after the shooting. The shooting sparked racial tensions in the community because citizens thought Lt. Edwards would not be prosecuted. On July 31, the black community in RedSprings expressed outrage over the release of James Edwards under a $75,000 secured bond. Family members and black community leaders questioned Edwards's release. (July 4, Fayetteville Observer; July 15, Red Springs Citizen; August 5, Red Springs Citizen) July 7. The NC House approved a bill that would rnake it illegal to teach techniques used in hate crimes. Senator Robert Carpenter, R-Macon, introduced the bill after discovering neo-Nazi sympathizer William Pierce owned property in Carpenter's district. There were rumors that Pierce would turn the property, originally the site of the Church of the Creator, into a paramilitary compound. The House approved the measure 9~9. It would be a misdemeanor punishable by a prison term of up to two years, a fine, or both to teach techniques used in crimes of racial, ethnic, or religious bias. (July 8, Wilmington Morning Star) O #82. July 8, Guilford Co. A caller reported that a chapter of the White Aryan Resistance (WAR) has formed in Jamestown. He said he had been to the home of its organizers and wanted to expose them. The number given to NCARRV had been disconnected. (NCARRV victim report) July 12, Orange Co. A group of parents expressed opposition to the Chapel Hill/Carrboro School Board's plan to include sexual orientation in the schools' multicultural curriculum. The school board meeting was the first in a long battle against inclusion of gay and lesbian culture in the school board's multicultural plan. (July 14, Durham Herald-Sun) July 15, Rowan Co. The American Civil Liberties Union filed suit on behalf of the Christian Knights of the Ku Klux Klan against the City of Statesville and the Statesville Police Department. Filed by ACLU attorneys William Simpson, Jr. and Samuel Fritschner, the suit was brought because "Klan leaders were not satisfied with the route in which (sic) they were given to hold a march." (July 16, Statesville Record and Landmark) H X #83. July 16-17, Wake Co. ~ man listed in the phone book as a gay/lesbian counselor received multiple harassing calls saying "All faggots should die" and "We're gonna get you." In one instance, a father discovered his son calling for an appointment and re-dialed to harass the counselor. The calls still continue at about five a week. (NCCGLE) V #84. July 16, Vance Co. Vandals spraypainted swastikas, "KKK", and a satanic symbol on trash dumpsters near Belmont Drive in Henderson. The vandalism occurred one week after vandals defaced school buses at Northern Vance High School. (July 17, Henderson Daily Dispatch) July, Durham Co. A letter written by a minority task force at Duke University created stirs of anti-Semitism after the letter criticized top officials with "trying to establish a Jewish connection". Duke University President Nan Keohane responded with a letter to the local and national NAACP offices, vowing to work with the task force on issues raised over workplace discrimination. The task force later stated "lt was never the intention of our committee to tarnish the reputation of the Jewish community, which has historically cooperated in the Civil Rights struggle for equality." (July 27, Raleigh News and Observer) A Y #85. July 21, Rockingham Co. A black teen was assaulted at Madison High School by two white youths from Marshall. Daniel Ramsey, 17, and James Chandler, 18, were both charged with ethnic intimidation after they assaulted Sam Thomas, 16. Chandler was also charged with assault with a deadly weapon for attempting to run over Thomas. Ramsey was cited as one of three teenagers who assaulted Thomas last November on a school bus. The three youths were sentenced to 30 days in jail and the convictions were appealed. Both Chandler and Ramsey were in a pickup truck when they attempted to run over Thomas. They got out of the truck and "wrestled Thomas to the ground and started punching him in the head." One of the youths reportedly yelled at Thomas "You're not black, you're just a -ing nigger!" Thomas is one of two black students at Madison High School. On November 16, Daniel Ramsey pled guilty to a lesser charge of misdemeanor assault, was given a 1-year sentence suspended for two years, a $250 fine, and 100 hours of community service. The other defendant, Jamie Chandler, did not go to trial. His charge was deferred by the district attorney in exchange for 50 hours of community service. (July 29, Marshall News Record, July 24, Asheville Citizen-Times, November 17, Asheville Citizen-Times) A Y #86. July 29, Orange Co. In Chapel Hill, police break up a fight on Franklin Street between black and white youth who were/ shouting racial epithets. Police Chief Ralph Pendergraph was quoted as saying "One of the groups has a connection to the Skinheads and has ties to a Skinhead organization in Charlotte." (July 32, Chapel Hill Herald, August 1, Chapal Hill Newspaper) A Y #87. July 31, Orange Co. Three white UNC students were assaulted by a group of black youth. The incident caused alarm in Chapel Hill after a string of racially motivated fights on Franklin Street. (August 4, Chapel Hill Herald) AUGUST ** A X #88. August, Catawaba Co. A gay man was struck twice in the back of the head, hit in the face and kicked by a man who shouted "I hate you faggots!" As the case neared trial, the assailant harassed the witnesses, even spray-painted one witness's car and threatened to beat and shoot her. The caller said both the police and the D.A. were supportive. (NCARRV victim's report,NCCGLE) V X #89. August, Cumberland Co. Someone carved "Faggots die" on a sign in a public park. (NCCGLE) O #90. August 1, Rowan Co. Two Klansmen dressed in robes and hoods were cited in Salisbury for impeding the flow of traffic. Charged were twenty-five year old Thomas Robert Moore, from Asheboro and thirty-two year old Jesse Wayne Barnes of Franklinville. (August 5, Denton Record) H #91. August 2, Lenior Co. A La Grange resident spoke at a town council meeting about a police officer and volunteer firemen who used racial slurs in the community. The resident, a member of the Black Alliance, said the police officer frequently used the word "nigger" and volunteer fireman yelled racial slurs and told blacks "Get off the street" and "We're going to get you" at a July 3 march sponsored by the Black Alliance. (August 3, Kinston Free Press) H X #92. August 3, Forsyth Co. A group of women playing softball reported that they were called "dykes" and "sicko" by a group of young men. (NCCGLE) M #93. August 5, Gaston Co. In Gastonia a black teenager murdered a white teenager in what police suggest was a "racially motivated" attack. Eighteen year old Brian Desmond Worthy was charged with the murder of nineteen year old Robert Allen Burns. Burns was hit in a drive-by shooting. Others may be charged with the murder also. (December 17, Gastonia Gazette) X #94. August 6, Cumberland Co. Kenneth Junior French, a 22-year-old Army sergeant stationed at Fort Bragg, entered a restaurant wearing a hunting vest and armed with two 12-gauge shotguns, a .22-caliber rifle, and extra ammunition. According to Sgt. Mike Ballard, witness Dawn Gabriel, and victim Eddie Burnett, French spoke loudly about "Clinton letting faggots in the military" while firing. There is no evidence suggesting French thought any of the people he shot were gay. Killed were: Wesley Scott Cover, 26; James F. Kidd, 46; Ethel Parrous, 65; and Pete Parrous, '73. Wounded were: Jeffrey Bradstreet; Eddie Burnett, 38; Phillip Fornabio, 40; Connie Kotsopoulos, 39; Willie McCormick, 51; Rick Parmee; and Rona Woods, 23. (NCCGLE) O #95. August 7, Macon Co. Ben Klassen, leader and founder of the Church of the Creator, was found dead at his home. Investigators ruled the death a suicide. Klassen reportedly took an overdose of sleeping pills. At his side was a copy of his book, The White Man's Bible. The Church of the Creator is a part of the Christian Identity movement which claims that white people are the true descendants of Christ, Jews are "children of the Devil", and blacks and other people of color are "Pre-Adamic" and "subhuman". Just before Klassen's death, members of his group were part of a failed attempt to start a race war in Los Angeles where they planned to bomb a black church and target black and Jewish leaders. (August 11, Charlotte Observer) A #96. August 8, Onslow Co. Two white Camp Lejeune Marines were charged with assault with a deadly weapon with intent to kill after their participation in a drive-by shooting with racial overtones. Twenty-two year old Lance Cpls Christopher S. Bush and Brian K. Folk shot at blacks while making racial remarks. (August 10, Charlotte Observer) O #97. August 8-9, Lincoln Co. Members of the Christian Knights of the Ku Klux Klan marched in Lincolnton and hosted a state rally the following day. (police intelligence) August 9, Columbus Co. Tabor City's black police chief is fired by Town Manager Al Leonard for undisclosed reasons. Willie Gore, the town's first black police chief, maintains he was fired because he signed time cards for other employees and that a body shop owner signed for parts for a police car at an auto-parts store. Two hundred people marched on August 21st in protest. (August 23, Charlotte Observer) August 13, Nash Co. Four individuals charged with attempting to start a riot last year in Rocky Mount were given long prison sentences to prove, in the words of Assistant District Attorney Keith Werner, "the state will not put up with this type of lawlessness in the area." The incident happened last fall when four white teenagers on a "hate spree" burned a mobile classroom and shot a black man. Two of the youth were given twenty years, a third given fifteen years. (August 13, Rocky Mount Telegram) O #98. August 14, Scotland Co. Members of the Christian Knights of the Ku Klux Klan marched in Laurinburg. (police intelligence) S X #99. August 16, Mecklenburg Co. A gay man called to report that a grocery store cashier muttered "dumb faggot" under her breath after an effeminate man in front of the caller took a long time putting away his change. Caller reported the cashier's mutter to the customer service desk. (NCCGLE) O #100. August 21, Harnett Co. Members of the Christian Knights of the Ku Klux Klan marched in Pineview. (yolice intelligence) O #101. August 28, New Hanover Co. Twenty-seven members of the Christian Knights of the Ku Klux Klan marched in Wilmington. Some of them reportedly carried guns and machetes. They were protected by 150 of ficers from the Wilmington Police Department and the New Hanover Sheriff's Department. Forty people gathered at a peaceful protest demonstration planned by area churches at another site. Taxpayers paid $20,000 in overtime costs for officers because of the march. A proposal that "any group posing a threat of violence" should pay an insurance bond did not meet the approval of city of ficials. (August 29, September 14, Wilmington Morning Star) A X #102. August 29, Nash Co. A gay man reading a newspaper in Battle Park was beaten with a stick by two men who told him "Low-life faggots like you don't deserve to live." The men said police patrols (which target gay men and arrest them for picking up other gay men in the park) were "not doing enough to clean up the park" and they were taking it into their hands to "do the job right." After forcing the gay man to play Russian roulette, the two men took his clothes, wallet and car keys, smashed his car windows, then walked away and watched as he got a shirt from his car and walked out the road for help. The caller was hospitalized with a collapsed lung, stitches, and bruises. The caller also reported that police were indifferent and acted as if he deserved to be beaten. When he asked for their help, one officer said "But we are trying to stop gays in the park." Officer McGraff told NCCGLE that police are not investigating the case because they do not have enough information. (NCCGLE) M #103. August 29, Durham Co. A Hispanic man was gunned down in a Durham county neighborhood after a resident asked him to leave. Twenty-two year old Simon Rodriguez was shot by nineteen year old Rodger Lane Freeland because Rodriguez was waiting for gas for his stalled car. (August 31, Durham Herald-Sun) L #104. August 30, Macon Co. A caller reported racist literature stuffed inside newspaper rack copies of the Atlanta Constitution. The flyers were announcements of the National Vanguard Books, believed to be a business run by neo-Nazi William Pierce. (NCARRV victim's report) S Y #105. August 31, Cumberland Co. A white drum major at the predominantly black college Fayetteville State University stepped down after catcalls and racial epithets were yelled at him on several occasions. (September 2, Charlotte Observer) H X #106. Late August, Wake Co. A harassing phone call was received by a NC State activist whose phone number was listed on fliers advertising the group's first meeting. (NCCGLE) H X #107. Late August, Wake Co. An NC State University student activist driving down Hillsborough St. was harassed by two men in a pick-up with NC State stickers, who threw a cup of ice in her window and yelled "Faggot." (NCCGLE) SEPTEMBER ** L X #108 September, Wake Co. Someone put up flyers in shower stalls at NCSU warning men that gays wanted to have sex with them. (NCCGLE) H X #109. September 2, Wake Co. A lesbian received a telephoned death threat the night after the NCSU paper ran an editorial she wrote supporting National Coming Out Day. (NCCGLE) X #110. September 2, Vance Co. A victim visited NCARRV's office to report that he has been followed for some time by men driving cars with Georgia license tags. The victim believes the incident started when he moved next door to a man speculatively linked to the Klan. The victim, who is black, had his home damaged and his property vandalized. The county sheriff's department have been unable to charge anyone with the defacement of his property and he has hired a private investigator. (NCARRV victim's report) A #111. September 6, Buncombe Co. Blacks and whites clashed in Asheville at a Westem Steer restaurant. Shots were fired and one person was hit in the finger. No one was charged. (September 7, Asheville Citizen-Times) September 6, Lee Co. Members of the Wake County NAACP went to Sanford to confiscate office equipment from the Invisible Empire Knights of the Ku Klux Klan. (September 10, Raleigh News and Observer, NCARRV) H X #112. September 7, Durham Co. An interracial lesbian couple reported receiving death threats at their home. A swastika was painted on a rock near their home and threats were circulated among people close to them. (NCARRV victim's report) H X #113. September 9, Pitt Co. A gay man listed as contact for a gay, lesbian and bisexual group received a harassing message. (NCCGLE) V #114. September 17, Wake Co. A home in Gamer was vandalized with references to the KKK, racial slurs, and Satanic syrnbols. (September 29, Garner News) Y #115. September 17, Durham Co. Rumors of racial conflict at Southem High School prompted school administrators to ask white students not to wear cowboy hats. Apparently a group of white teens dressed with cowboy hats were sus-pected of instigating a confrontation with black students at the school. White students were angered, pointing to black students wearing Malcolm X hats and T-shirts to school. (Septetnber 18, Durham Herald-Sun) O O #116,#117. September 18, Randolph Co. Twenty members of the Christian Knights of the Ku Klux Klan marched in Asheboro and Randleman. (September 22, Randletnan Reporter) H X #118. September 23, Mecklenburg Co. After an MCC church (which ministers primarily to lesbians and gay men) purchased land in Mathews, its pastor received death threats and harassing calls. Led by Cindy Faw, members of nearby Baptist Bible Church organized to run the church out of their neighbor-hood. The group has harassed church members during services, filed a petition to revoke the church's zoning ordinance, and alleged that church members molest children. (NCCGLE) September 23, Forsyth Co. One of the four white men charged with the brutal murder and castration of a black man was released from jail, serving barely 16 months. Assistant Distrlct Attorney Vince Rabil claimed Dwayne Gregory Doby received death threats and may be needed as a witness in upcoming appeals. (Setttember 23, Winston-Salem Chronicle) A Y #119. September 23, Cleveland Co. Two fights between black and white students at Kings Mountain High School in Kings Mountain led to the suspension of six students. The following day police confiscated a baseball bat and a knife from students. (September 30, Kings Mountain Herald) A #120. September 24, Orange Co. Kyle Noriega, a white man from Durham, was assaulted by a group of black teenagers. He described the beating to the Chapel Hill Herald as follows: "All of a sudden a group of blacks stepped out of the shadows of an alley. The leader came forward and cold hit me to the ground. The next thing I know, these dadgum niggers were all over mebeating the sh-- out of me." (September 26, Chapel Hill Herald) H X #121. September 28, Wayne Co. A lesbian reported she and her partner were being harassed by their neighbor who yelled slurs from his front yard and damaged their home. (NCCGLE) L #122. September 29, Chatham Co. In Siler City, bright red stickers proclaiming "Earth's Most Endangered Species: THE WHITE RACE. Help Preserve it. Write of call the National Alliance in Hillsboro, West Virginia" were scattered throughout the city. (September 30, Siler City News) H X #123. Late September, Orange Co. Someone threw a brick through the second floor window of an openly gay student at UNC. It was reported to campus police. (NCCGLE) OCTOBER ** O #124. October 2, Cleveland Co. Twelve members of the Christian Knights of the Ku Klux Klan marched in Shelby. Twenty officers provided police protection. (October 4, Shelby Daily Star) A Y #125. October 9, Johnston Co. Racial tensions were displayed when a group of white youths accosted a group of black youths in Clayton. The white youth were dnnking outside a game room when they decided to "cross the railroad tracks" and assault a group of black youths. Officers and sheriff's deputies were called to break up the fight. The newspaper reported there were 200 black and white youth involved. (October 11, Raleigh News and Observer) F X #126. October 9, Onslow Co. Someone broke into Danny Leonard's home, doused his bed with diesel or jet fuel, and set the home ablaze, causing $72,000 - $80,000 in damages. Leonard received a phone call the night before the arson which said "We're gonna get you good this time faggot." After the arson, someone called saying, "We fixed you good this time faggot. Next time we'll finish you off." A week later, someone called to boast, "I broke down your door, poured gas on your bed and burnt your house down. I'm gonna do the same to the bar and kill you." (NCCGLE) S X #127. October 9, GuiUord Co. Fans at a UNC Greensboro soccer game shouted homophobic slurs at the opposing team. (NCCGLE) O O #128,#129. October 9, Nash Co. Members of the Christian Knights of the Ku Klux Klan marched in Middlesex and Bailey. (police intelligence) October 11, Wayne Co. (GLHWC) - In Goldsboro, a man walking down the street was called a "fag" and ridiculed when a car full of teenage boys passed him. (NCCGLE) H X #130. October 15, Durham Co. A gay man doing his laundry at a White Star laundromat was harassed by two men who started to come after him. The following day the victim passed by one of the men on the street who shouted at him, "I see you made it out of the laundromat alive." (NCCGLE) O #131. October 16, Cabarrus Co. Thirty members of the Christian Knights of the Ku Klux Klan marched in Concord. (October 17, Concord Tribune) October 24, Durham Co. A white youth possibly took advantage of racial problems in Durham when he said he and a friend were attacked by a gang of black teenagers on Hoover Rd. The youth first reported that they were in the neighborhood looking at a truck advertised for sale. It was later discovered that the youth were there to buy drugs. The other youth died as a result of his injuries. (October 25, 26, 28, Durham Herald-Sun) NOVEMBER ** H X #132. November, Orange Co. An openly gay UNC student received harassing phone calls once or twice a day for weeks. (NCCGLE) H #133. November 1, Durham Co. A Durham woman reported burn marks resembling a cross in her yard. Police were investigating it as a possible hate crime. (November 3, Durham Herald Sun) O #134. November 6, Guilford Co. Twenty-five members of the Christian Knights of the Ku Klux Klan marched in Greensboro. They were protected by 235 law enforcement of ficers, costing the city $29,000. (November 11, Greensboro News and Record) V X #135. November 8, Purham Co. A victim reported vandalism to his car which had several gay stickers on it. "Fag" was written in black permanent marker across windows, mirrors and bumper stickers. (NCCGLE) A Y #136. November 14, Orange Co. In Chapel Hill, a black teenager was charged with four counts of ethnic intimidation after an altercation with four men, one of whom was black. The victims reported being assaulted after a group of 15 black teenagers exchanged words with the four men. The black teenager charged reportedly called the black victim an "Oreo" because he was with three white men. On January 7, 1994, Judge Lowry Betts sentenced Jamel K. Burnette, 17, and Dimitrius G. Mullins, 17, to four days active jail time (2 weekends each), one year suspended sentence, two years supervised probation, 50 hours community service, an 11:30 pm curfew, and ordered to pay the victim's medical bill of $7,000. (November 15, January 8, Chapel Hill Herald, November 15, Raleigh News and Observer, November 19, Chapel Hill Newspaper) Y #137. November 17, Lincoln Co. Fifty West Lincoln High School students were suspended following a protest over the "phasing out of one of the school's long-time symbols, the Confederate Battle Flag". Principal Kelly Childers decided the school emblem, removed from band and athletic uniforms, was a threat to the safety of the students when they travelled to other schools. West Lincoln High School is mostly white. Later in the week, 125 students protested, calling for a student advisory committee. In a meeting with Associate Superintendent Ed Hatley recommendations were given to keep the flag, including putting a slogan on the flag, "Heritage, Not Hate". (November 17, Lincolnton Times News, and November 19, Charlotte Observer) M X #138. November 21, Chatham Co. Carlos Rubino murdered Troy Joseph Dison. Dison was hit in the back of the head with a vase and was slashed with a knife. Rubino said he attacked Dison after Dison made a sexual advance. (NCCGLE) H X #139. November 22, Western NC. A white gay man reported that he and his African-American partner, both in college on athletic scholarships, were illegally videotaped by their teammates while the two men were having sex. The coach made the two men watch the illegal tape with him as he made degrading homophobic comments, and brought honor court charges against the men to have them dismissed from school. The honor court voted to take no action and promised to destroy the illegal tape. Both men received numerous harassing calls at home. (NCCGLE) V X #140. November 22-27, Wake Co. When a lesbian student parked her car near NC State's campus, someone cracked the right rear passenger window and wrote "F--- queer" in chalk on the car. Police said they could not do anything because she could not prove the writing and the vandalism were related. (NCCGLE) DECEMBER ** Y #141. December 10, Alamance Co. Racial tensions peaked at Burlington's Williams High School after "colored" and "white" signs were displayed at the school's water fountains. Students left school early for fear of violence. (December 11, Burlington Times-News, AGALA) December 10, Halifax Co. Black and white county employees held separate Christmas parties this year. The party was held at the Scotfield Country Club, which blacks in the community say does not welcome them. Whites gathered there while black employees gathered at a local restaurant. (December 20, Charlotte Observer) L #142. December 13, Catawba Co. In Hickory an interracial couple found a Klan calling card on their car windshield. The card read "The Knights of the Ku Klux laan are watching you and we don't like what we see". (December 14, Hickory Daily Record) December 22, Durham Co. Woman reported that in the Durham Regional Hospital a man called her a "dyke". (NCCGLE) OTHER INCIDENTS ** S X #143. Spring, Durham Co. A Riverside High School accounting teacher joked freely about "fags" during class. A gay youth in the class asked OutRight! to write the coach a letter. (NCCGLE) H X #144. Summer, Durham Co. Caregiver at a residency for people living with AIDS reported that three times during the summer a car filled with male teenagers drove by shouting anti-gay slurs. (NCCGLE) A X #145. Fall, Transylvania Co. A 16-year-old gay youth was repeatedly assaulted by his schoolmates when they found out he was gay. One schoolmate tried to kill him by jerking him out of a car. On December 9, the youth moved to a group home so that he could, in his words, "go back to high school and get away from all the hurt, pain, danger and harassment." (NCCGLE) Fall, Orange & Durham Co. Five gay parents from the Chapel Hill school system reported that their children were harassed. One child was verbally abused on a school bus, the others were harassed on the playground. (NCCGLE) A X #146. Winter, Wake Co. An Afrlcan-American fraternity at NC State assaulted and kicked out a pledge because he was rumored to be gay. The man was hospitalized and withdrew from school. (NCCGLE) H X #147. 1993, Cumberland Co. Employees and patrons at aub Oz, a gay bar, reported numerous slashed tires and harassing calls. (NCCGLE) 1993, Buncombe Co. Local hotline told NCCGLE about one reported instance of anti-gay vandalism but gave no details in order to protect confidentiality. (NCCGLE) "There is little hope for us until we become toughminded enough to break loose from the shackles of prejudice, half-truths, and downright ignorance." Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. POLICE/COMMUNITY RELATIONS: CONFLICT AND UNREST CONTINUE The "age-old problem" of police and community friction, as identified by the Community Relations Service of the United States Justice Department, became a critical concern for North Carolinians Against Racist and Religious Violence in 1989. Following our monitoring efforts of six years, we noted a marked increase of almost 100 percent for that year over the previous three years in the number of suspects' deaths occurring while in police custody or while being apprehended. With the release of a special report in 1990, "NO REVERENCE FOR LIFE? POLICE USE OF DEADLY FORCE IN NORTH CAROLINA", one full year before the Rodney King incident in Los Angeles brought this issue to the front burner of current social debate, NCARRV began to raise hard and unpopular questions about the pervasive climate of fear andmistrust which fuels this phenomenon. We believed our focus to be right on the mark, especially in light of the overriding racially charged characteristic of the conflict. We raised such questions as: Is the violence attributable to police brutality or self defense? Is what we are seeing due to lack of respect for the law or lack of respect for those perceived criminal? What works best, a strong-armed militaristic approach or a human relations centered negotiation style? We also offered recommendations for remedies which included: more active participation by citizens in the policing process in their communities and in the review process when allegations of excessive force surface; mandating by law the civilian review of agencies facing allegations of excessive force; the development and implementation of a uniform firearms policy governing law enforcements' discharge of weapons by the North Carolina Criminal Justice Education and Training Standards Commission; and systematic record-keeping and reporting on police use of deadly force by the Police Information Network with targeted information which would clearly indicate the relationship of violence against and by police. While citizens have taken an active role in advocacy for their involvement in policing their communities, as suggested by these recommendations, official steps toward implementing them have been slow to non-existent. "Community Oriented Policing" practices have been implemented in some agencies and increase human relations training for officers in some departments across North Carolina. Even so the conflict continues and the climate of fear and mistrust prevails - on the part of citizens and police alike. That social reality resonated unequivocally for us at NCARRV, as we prepared documentation for the release of this report. The 27 incidents logged account for alleged assaults by officers on citizens, racial slurs directed a police and by police at citizens, instances of riots an racially motivated community unrest, inappropriate police response, and death. Citizens in communities we hear from express their understanding of the need for, and in fact desire police protection, especially in light of the larger climate of violence and crime in our society. Their frustrations center around what verges on "police occupation" in their communities which are perceived to be "criminal" or "drug infested" . They resent being labeled "hostile" when they react to more than three police cars responding with riot-geared officers to a simple disturbance. The disturbance is exacerbated by such "show of force" and winds up in a dangerous power play between community and police. Individuals - particularly African American men, articulate their outrage at being held at gunpoint and often handcuffed as a result of mistaken identity. Six of the logged cases in this section are attributed to conflict and tension in those categories. Law enforcement professionals face a different yet equally intensified strain in these highly charged situations. As they embrace their mandate to protect and defend the public and their own lives, they also must grapple with making the transition from traditional paramilitaristic police culture to a more personal approach of negotiation and problem-solving. A new set of skills are required when officers feel they are "out-gunned" and out-numbered by the criminals. The capacity for a clear judgement call wanes in dangerous situations, and fear for personal safety becomes paramount. In the absence of these new skills, the objective is to subdue a suspect at any cost and end the threat. Seven deaths of susnects which occured while in the custody of police or during apprehension by officers are included in this section. While three of the suspects were alleged by officers to be armed, none of them returned fire. A Rockingham County man sustained 11 gunshot wounds after allegedly pointing a shotgun at officers following a domestic dispute. A Selma man, Charles Nathaniel Smith, was shot by three police officers and died on the scene, and Kenneth Brian Fennell of Goldsboro was shot by a Randolph County officer following a speeding citation stop and a scuffle. Unarmed Daron LaMont Bines died after he was shot by Winston-Salem officer E.F. Gene Piscitelli after seeking to intervene in a struggle with the officer and another man. Windy Gail Thompson was shot four times and killed by Charlotte officer Mark Farmer who alleges she tried to drag him with her car following a suspected drunken driving stop. The "pepper spray" deaths of 26 year-old Angelo Robinson of Concord and a Winston-Salem man, Lawrence Francisco Cannon, 52 years old, occurred when officers used the mace to subdue them during arrest. Pepper spray mace was also used on a crowd in Columbus county following a disturbance at a Tabor City town council meeting, which resulted in community unrest. Two cases of inappropriate police response were logged when calls came into the NCARRV office. Members of the Durham Service Corps, a community service and education program, related how they had been falsely accused of attempted robbery by a nervous Durham resident and had been handcuffed and held at gunpoint by North Carolina Central University Campus Police with Durham City Police cooperation. There were also questions from citizens following the release of information by the Durham Police Department that a black gang was raping and kidnapping white women as partof an initiation rite. The police recanted the story after public outcry. We learned again from these incidents that police departments bear a unique responsibility in shaping community views about crime and its perpetrators; Hasty judgements based on misinformation from the community or on officers' preconceptions can easily lead to embarrassment or even tragedy. The challenge posed here for departments appears to be their need to investigate carefully from a non-confrontational posture before responding to any given situation. In 1993, there were also police convictions and discharges stemming from citizens' mistreatment. Two of six officers in Gaston County were convicted on charges of abusing street people. A Hoke County officer was convicted of assault following an arrest where he beat a suspect with his baton. A Statesville officer was discharged following allegations of excessive use of force in a domestic dispute call. In light of the incidents revealed in this section a number of questions immediately surface. How do we diffuse the ongoing climate of mistrust and fear between police and communities, undergirded by the perception that one group, particularly identified by race or age, is more criminal than another? Shouldn't the use of pepper gas mace be halted until there have been conclusive studies about its toxic nature, given the deaths we know have followed its use? How do we ensure that the "Community Oriented Policing" approach is embraced statewide by law enforcement agencies, across the board? How do we really restore peace and mutual respect in our communities? It is clearly our sense at NCARRV that these questions deserve serious consideration and must be answered if we hope to de-escalate the pervasive climate of violence and conflict with police in our communities. RECOMMENDATIONS FOR REMEDY OF POLICE AND COMMUNITY CONFLICT Some very positive steps have been taken across the state by police agencies who have embraced Community Oriented Policing as an approach to create the potential forpartnership relations in communities. The Durham Police Department, as a model, includes components such as Crime Area Target Teams (CATT) which places officers in "high crime area" communities in order to restore safety for residents. They have also developed community work and dialogue groups like the North East Central Durham Partners Against Crime Group, comprised of police and residents who have a pulse on what is happening and are working together to build positive perceptions and relationships. These approaches, while admirable, still only address the symptoms of a problem that is otherwise almost out of control. We strongly encourage and recommend that police agencies explore partnership relations with community based organizations to develop projects which offer skills training and entrepreneurial opportunities to traditionally disempowered and unemployed juveniles. These kind of projects may serve as the strongest deterrent to young people seeking money and respect and who often believe they find both through criminal behavior. Creating opportunities for sustainable income and realization of one's total potential is the truest way to prevent crime. As we at NCARRV have continually stressed, there is a need for active citizens participation in policing their communities. We also believe citizens must have a voice through a Citizen's Review Process when allegations of police misconduct or charges of excessive use of force emanate from the community. The cases logged in this section point to the fact that the underlying problems have not been ameliorated. In light of the apparent success Durham's department is having with their North East Central Durham Partners Against Crime Group, we suggest that this kind of structure could be a model for dealing with such matters. The very nature of these groups, through careful nurturing, information sharing and exchange, and mutually respectful relationship building between communities and local departrnents, should guarantee that the interests of all are served. We would further recommend that this structure be empowered to monitor complaints through constant contact with their departments, and to make appropriate recommedations. CHRONOLOGY 1993 Incidents of Police and Community Conflict December 31,1992, Gaston Co. A Gastonia man claimed he was assaulted by police officers in an unmarked car on New Year's Eve. When he refused to pull his car over. Vincent Pressley was stopped for driving with expired registration tags and was charged with resisting arrest, driving with expired registration tags, and failure to stop for a blue light and siren. (January 9, Gaston Gazette) January, Gaston Co. Two of six police officers charged with abusing street people received prison terms. The officers were charged with harassing homeless people by pouring cooking oil and urine on them and by beating them. Charges surfaced in 1990 after complaints were filed. Controversy surrounded the case after the city paid victims money in exchange for keeping quiet. (January 23 Charlotte Observer; January 23 Gaston Gazette) January 5, Durham Co. The Durham Police Department informed the public of a black gang that "kidnaps and rapes white women as a rite of initiation". Following questions emanating from the community, police maintain the information was given to them by an informant. They recanted the story a few days later. (January 6, Durham Herald-Sun) January 10, Cumberland Co. A Fayetteville man filed a complaint against a Highway Patrol officer stating that the officer assaulted him with a heavy, metal flashlight to the face. The victim's wife sat in the car while the assault occurred. (January 26, Fayetteville Obsever-Times) February 18, Rockingham Co. A man pointed a shotgun at police and is shot eleven times and killed when he charges at them. March 28, Orange Co. A black Chapel Hill resident complained after police pointed a gun at his head after mistaking him for a robbery suspect. The same weekend, a black Fort Bragg Army sergeant and his brother were handcuffed and interrogated by police at gunpoint, also as a result of mistaken identity. One of the officers allegedly commented that "all blacks look alike." After public outcry and a police investigation, Police Chief Ralph Pendergraph stated in the April 2 edition of the Chapel Hill Herald that "These were felony vehicle stops and under this policy officers are allowed to draw weapons, although with no finger on the trigger." Officers were going on the description of "black man driving a red car". (March 29, April 3, Chapel Hill Herald) April 11, Johnston Co. A Selma man was shot by three of ficers after he stole his girlfriend's truck at gunpoint. Officers responding to the call said twenty-seven year old Charles Nathaniel Smith was armed with a .38 semi-automatic pistol. He was told four tirnes to drop the weapon. When he didn't respond, Officer David Allen fired. The other two officers at the scene fired also. Smith died at the scene. The officers were placed on paid administrative leave pending an investigation. (April 13, Raleigh News and Observer; April 13 Smithfield Herald) Duplin/Wayne Co. Mount Olive Police Chief John Wilson was the subject of a petition asking for his removal. Residents point to Wilson's abusive treatment of two black teenage residents and his management style as reasons for dismissal. Earlier this year Wilson was accused of using excessive force in the apprehension of two unarmed black teenagers. Wilson reportedly threw the teens to the ground, handcuffed them and held them at gunpoint. Prior to becoming Chief of Mount Olive, Wilson was head of mall security at Crabtree Valley Mall, which became the subject of mistreatment of African-American customers, particularly black youth. Wilson was asked to resign after the mall agreed to pay a $12,292 settlement to a black youth who charged he was struck and injured by a security guard. (April 15, Raleigh News and Observer) April 25, Lee Co. When police were called to a Sanford community to break up a fight, tensions created a riot where tear gas was used to disperse a crowd gathered to witness the incident at Turner Drive. Community residents expressed their outrage at the way the police handled the situation, claiming that tear gas was not necessary. (April 27 and 28, Sanford Herald) April 29, New Hanover Co. What was termed a "hostile crowd" gathered to throw bottles at police officers who were in the Creekwood area to arrest a man on trespass charges. An officer was responding to a call of loiterers in the area when he spotted the man, who had a previous drug charge. Because of that drug charge, he was to be arrested on sight. The suspect reportedly resisted arrest, another officer "unintentionally struck the suspect in the upper body, possibly in the head area", as the suspect charged the officer. A crowd gathered, throwing rocks and shouting "Rodney King". It was the second time in six weeks that a crowd gathered in such a response during a police arrest. Lt. J.L Yost, head of the career criminal section of the Wilmington Police Department was quoted as saying: ". . . to us, it'snot black and white; it's people choosing to behave in a certain way. You need to ask one question: Did the man submit willfully? The answer is going to be 'No'." The suspect, Wayne Lamont Clark, later filed a complaint. An investigation completed a month later by the Wilmington Police Department concluded that the officers did not use excessive force. (May 1, 4 and 25, Wilmington Morning Star) May 3, Durham Co. A student from North Carolina Central University filed a complaint against Duke University's Public Safety Department after he and three other students were detained upon leaving Duke's Perkins library. Kyle Jackson, a pre-law student, and a friend were on campus using the library when they offered two friends a ride. Public Safety of ficers stopped them just as they were leaving the library and ordered the occupants of the car to put their hands on the dash. Jackson maintains that when he asked why he was stopped, he was told to keep his hands on the dashboard and was not given any explanation. Chief A.B. Washington of Public Safety later said the car was stopped because one of the occupants of the car was suspected of stealing a bookbag from the library. No one was charged. Jackson filed a formal complaint. (May 4, Durham Herald-Sun) May 8, Cumberland Co. It is reported that a Cumberland Co. Sheriff's deputy was placed on paid administrative leave following a complaint that he beat a handcuffed suspect. The incident occurred following a disturbance at a tavern where the suspect could not find his wife. The woman apparently left after the suspect was involved in a fight at the tavern. The suspect was charged with damage to personal property and trespassing after he kicked the dashboard of the patrol car and kicked at the deputy. (May 8, Greensboro News and Record) May 14, Durham Co. An off-duty Sheriff's deputy reportedly used racially offensive comments while breaking up a fight between two students at Southern High School. The remarks allegedly occurred after a student involved in the brawl assaulted the deputy. The student was charged with assault. (May 19, Durham Herald-Sun) May 23, Rowan Co. The Statesville Record and Landmark reported that a police officer from the Statesville Police Department was fired for using excessive force during a call responding to a domestic dispute. (May 23, Statesville Record and Landmark) June 1, Forsyth Co. Winston-Salem police officer E.F. Gene Piscitelli shot and killed a man during a struggle with another man the officer saw smashing windows of a parked patrol car with a bicycle. Twenty-six year old Daron LaMont Bines died after being shot by Officer Piscitelli. Witnesses say Bines was trying to break up a struggle between Piscitelli and Richard Nathaniel Burns. During a struggle, the officer swung his billy club and sprayed Mace. People gathered to watch the fight and witnesses reported after Officer Piscitelli withdrew his 10 mm semiautomatic, he shot himself in the thigh before firing at Bines. In November, District Attorney Tom Keith cleared the officer of any wrongdoing. (June 2,4, Greensboro News and Record; November 4, Winston-Salern Chronicle) June 3, Hoke Co. A Raeford police of ficer was convicted of assaulting a suspect with a baton during a January arrest. Officer Locklear maintained the suspect jumped him after he was attacked. He was sentenced to six months in prison, suspended and placed on 18 months unsupervised probation. (June 4, Fayetteville Observer-Times) June 15, Guilford Co. An African American Highway Patrol Officer was charged with assault after he beat a drunk driver suspect. The suspect, William Lee, reportedly spit at the officer and called him a "nigger". Lee, who is white, was reportedly handcuffed at the time. Steve Evans, a five-year veteran of the Highway Patrol, was placed on unpaid suspension after the April 19 incident and was subsequently fired. (June 17, Greensboro News and Record, June 18, Charlotte Observer and June 18, Winston-Salem Journal) July, Durham Co. Members of the Durham Service Corps reported that their van was stopped and NCCU police officers held them at gun point after a false report that there was a gun in the van. The Durham Service Corp is located on North Carolina Central University's campus. Durham City police arrived and explained to corps members what was going on. A Durham resident became nervous when he saw young black men in his neighborhood (the service corp members were going around tagging city garbage bins). He called police to report he saw a gun. Members of the corp met with city representatives to express their concerns. (NCARRV victim report) July 11, Robeson Co. A Red Springs police car was shot into while an officer was inside. The car was struck five times, its headlight, front tire, and front fender hit. The shooting occurred when tensions were high due to the shooting of a black man by a white off-duty police officer. (July 25, Red Springs Citizen) July 11, Cabarrus Co. A twenty-four year old African American male lost his life at the hands of law enforcement in Concord. Angelo Robinson and an off-duty police officer exchanged words at the Waffle House in Concord. Backup assistance was requested by the officer and Robinson was continually sprayed with mace. Robinson, who had asthma, died enroute to the police department. The event touched off rioting and citywide curfews in the area. (July 12,13 Charlotte Observer, July 12, Goldsboro News Argus, July 13, Kannapolis Daily Independent) August 12, Cabarrus Co. Concord city aldermen voted to support state legislation that would create citizen review boards to review police actions. The vote came one month after Concord was rocked by rioters after the death of an African American male in police custody. Angelo Robinson died after police used mace on him during confrontation at a Waffle House. (August 15, Salisbury Post) August 30, Cabarrus Co. An autopsy report released by the state stated that pepper spray Mace contributed to the death of Angelo Robinson, who died while in police custody in July. Attorney General Mike Easley urged law enforcement agencies to suspend use of the spray until officers received more training on its use. "In my opinion, the cause of death in this case is asphyxia due to bronchospasm precipitated by the pepper spray. The decedent reportedly complained of respiratory difficulty and subsequently collapsed soon after being sprayed with the substance." Lisa M. Flannagan, assistant state medical examiner. (August 31, Raleigh News and Observer) August 30, Randolph Co. A black male was shot and killed by a Highway Patrol Officer after being stopped for speeding in Archdale. Kenneth Brian Fennell of Goldsboro was stopped and given a citation for driving without an operator's license. Trooper Stephenson said he found crack cocaine, a pistol and scales in the car. The victim and the officer then struggled and the trooper claimed he fired in self-defense. Trooper R.L. Stephenson was placed on administrative leave during investigation by the State Bureau of Investigation. (September 1, Wilmington Morning Star) September 24, New Hanover Co. A white man injured during a fight refused to cooperate with a police officer because he was black. Police were forced to return to the home of the victim three times to get a report. (September 25, Wilmington Morning Star) September 26, Johnston Co. A nineteen year old man was shot nine times and killed by a state Highway Patrol officer. The officer says he spotted Winfred Earl Boskey standing on the side of a road near a car. They struggled while two Department of Correction officers were flagged by a motorist and came to assist Trooper Charles Rogers. Rogers attempted to spray Boskey with Mace but instead sprayed himself in the eyes. The two then fell into the back of the police cruiser with Boskey on 'op. (September 28, Raleigh News and Observer) October 12, Columbus Co. Five supporters of former police chief Willie Gore were arrested for a disturbance at the Tabor City town council meeting. Gunshots were also heard and several parked cars were damaged. Community residents blamed the incident on the police, who many feel instigated the disturbance after supporters of Gore were asked to leave the town meeting. I'olice responded with pepper spray and the outbreak followed. Ada Spivey was quoted in the Wilmington Morning Star with saying "They fired the colored l,. and the colored people don't like it. But the colored got to realize that the colored people got to live just like us white folks got to live. Il they don't put somebody in their way, they're going to take it over, the colored people are." White resident Linell Fowler was quoted in the October 17 Wilmington Morning Star as saying "But all I'm asking is that they stay in their place and act like they should. They are not. They are trying to make white people come to them and its not going to work." (October 14, Raleigh News and Observer, Whiteville News Reporter, Wilmington Journal) October 19, Iredell Co. Statesville Police Officers arrested six people and charged them with inciting a riot after "50 hostile people in a high crime neighborhood" assaulted police with rocks. Officers say they were responding to reports of a disturbance. A crowd was asked to disperse and when they did not do so, officers responded by asking for assistance from the NC Highway Patrol and the Iredell Sheriff's Department. No injuries were reported. (October 21, Winston-Salem Journal) November 3, Forsyth Co. A man who lapsed into a coma after being sprayed with pepper spray by police in July died. Lawrence Francisco Cannon, 52 years old, was charged with trespassing and fighting at a convenience store in Winston-Salem. Cannon crawled into a nearby car and refused to leave. Officers forced him out, "struggled with him briefly", and sprayed him with pepper spray. Upon arrival at the Forsyth County Jail, a jailer refused to admit Cannon because he was stumbling. He was taken to Forsyth Memorial Hospital, but was unconscious in the back seat of a police car when it arrived. As of November 4, District Attorney Tom Keith had not decided whether police did anything improper. (November 4, Concord Tribune) December 29, Mecklenburg Co. In Charlotte, an African American woman was shot and killed by Officer Mark Farmer during a traffic stop for suspected drunk driving. Thirty-two year old Windy Gail Thompson was shot four times after Farmer maintains he was dragged by her car. After a chase that ended with Ms. Thompson's car in a utility pole, Farmer says he went around the passenger side of the suspect's car. With his arm hung in the window, Officer Farmer said Ms. Thompson took off, dragging him along. I le claims he fired to save his life. Community leaders questioned the amount of force used. (December 31, Charlotte Observer) UPDATE ON THE POLICE AND COMMUNITY RELATIONS PROJECT In 1991, with a one-time seed grant from the Episcopal Peace Fellowship, NCARRV launched a model criminal justice project to address police and community conflict, foster mutual respect and trust between police and citizens, and interrupt an escalating trend toward violence in our communities. Throughout 1991 and 1992 NCARRV brought the experience of monitoring police/community violence and working with victims to a collaboration with the Criminal Justice Department of North Carolina Central University (NCCU). A major goal was to convene an advisory board of law enforcement administrators, human relations workers, criminal justice experts, and community leaders in order to examine the dynamics of "police culture" and move toward developing "police and community partnerships". The project aimed to encourage ground-breaking research which might suggest training, policy,and additional needs for recommendations to state policing agencies for change. The advisory body was formed as a broad-based statewide representative group and met bi-monthly to provide project oversight and directions in shaping the two-year project. Initial research initiatives of assessing community perceptions surrounding police service delivery began in 1992, and data was collected in Durham, Graham, and Beaufort counties.In ligh tof thosei nitial findings, under the strong encouragement and guidance of the Advisory Board, the project was expanded to include assessing police agencies' perceptions. In 1993, with additional funding from the National Institute of Justice and guided by the research expertise at NCCU, the project initiative was honed to focus on rural policing initiatives. The Advisory Board is continuing to meet and the project is ongoing. An expanded timeframe now projects publication of the project's findings in March of 1995. NCARRV is currently involved on the project as a consultant in assisting to shape a community education and empowerment initiative. Summary and Recommendations The year of 1993 was earmarked by intensified acts of violence in North Carolina. While Klan organizing activity of marches and rallies diminished considerably, the occurrence of assault, community unrest amid racial tensions, and death were noted at an all-time high. The conspicuous absence of visible organized hate group activity validated for us at NCARRV the effectiveness the past ten years have had on planting seeds of hatred which undergird and offer support to individuals who commit acts of bigoted attack. The pervasive climate of violence which we are now seeing in the larger community and society cuts across gender, age, race, ethnicity, class, and sexual identity lines. As we have pointed out with the documentationof the 147 incidents logged in 1993, fear-based violence accounts for the majority of cases. That fear is overwhelmingly seeded in mistrust of those who are different and the heightened hysteria around crime and the perceptions of who are responsible for crime. This hysteria must be laid to rest and named as it realistically exists. It exists for the benefit of elected officials who capitalize upon this notoriety, hoping to gain support of voters who are made to feel protected and "safe". It also exists for the benefit of the media who gain readers and viewers from the hyped sensationalism. If national indicators can be believed, which suggest that crime is indeed diminishing in all categories except black on black crime, then the pivotal set of questions to be answered here is: who will fill newly built prisons supported by our tax dollars and appearing in the heart of our communities? Who will be sent to these newly established boot-camps touted as a possible deterrent for first-time youthful offenders? Who is destined to experience the "three strikes you're out" rule, which will determine life-long prison terms? Who currently bears the brunt of this hype around crime and ultimately loses across the board because we fail to think in terms of preventive strategies instead of intervention? These questions, while very hard-edged, must be answered as we watch the resources of our state and nation be siphoned off to address hysteria about crime instead of being used to create real and certain opportunities to build up our communities and our youth instead of the currently designed approaches aimed at locking up our youth. The swiftly approaching 21st century and the hope for a different kind of culture and society which values the dignity and worth of all of its population now places upon us some unique demands. Paramount among them - as ethnic and racial demographics shift - is that we think more critically and face with much more honesty the legacy of chaos our racially defined history has wrought. Particularly in light of how that history has determined who will remain impoverished or can be categorized "at risk" or become totally devalued over property. With the release of this report and as NCARRV grapples with many of the same challenges of the next millennium and those provided by the findings of 1993, we offer a number of recommendations for remedies that we believe will the move state toward restoring the values of human worth and dignity for all North Carolinians. We recommend that: Governor Jim Hunt recommission the state TaskForce on Racial, Religious, and Ethnic Intimidation and Violence. The Task Force develop an anti-bias curriculum for use in all public schools. A model can be gained from the National Association for the Education of Young Children. Human Relations Commissions be re-established in every county in North Carolina. Standards be developed for application of the Ethnic Intimidation Act to re-orient it toward its original "intended" purpose. Statistics on indictments and convictions under the Ethnic Intimidation Act be recorded and published. Sexual identity be included as a protected class in North Carolina's Ethnic Intimidation Act and that victims of this class qualify for compensation under the state's Civil Rights Interference Act. Summary of Recommendations for Police and Community Relations We recommend that: Police agencies explore partnership relationships with community based organizations to develop projects which offer skills and entrepreneurial opportunities to juveniles and young adults. Citizens participate in policing their communities A Citizens' Review Process be established to address allegations of police misconduct and/or excessive use of force. Model programs such as the North East Central Durham's Partners Against Crime Program be - extended to other areas in the state. Community/Police relations projects include the power for citizens to monitor complaints and make recommendations. North Carolinians Against Racist and Religious Violence P.O. Box 240 Durham, North Carolina 27702 919-688-5965